| Anyone who watched the Oscars knows that the operative self-congratulatory word for the night was "courage." John Irving, honored for adapting his 1985 novel The Cider House Rules, thanked the academy for honoring a film dealing with abortion and Miramax "for having the courage to make this movie in the first place." The audience burst into thunderous applause when he ended by thanking "everyone at Planned Parenthood" and the National Abortion Rights Action League.
In fact, the gratitude ought to run in the opposite direction. The film is
great public relations for the pro-abortion movement; it's a flattering
portrait of a gruff but kindly doctor who alternates between delivering
babies and aborting them in a rural orphanage. The film's message is that
moral maturity means understanding that life is complicated and that
certain rules don't apply in all circumstances.
Forgive me, but wouldn't a real display of courage be a film that
portrayed pro-lifers in at least two dimensions? Not easy, I grant you. It
would be very difficult for people in Hollywood to tell the story fairly
— let alone sympathetically — of people who don't run in their circles
and who, in their devotion to both mother and unborn child, fit no
stereotypes.
When it comes to depicting pro-lifers, is it possible that the film
industry may some day come of age? Can the public eventually expect
textured portraits of these people, many of whom have dedicated over 20
years of their lives to helping women and their unborn children?
Clearly, we have competing ideas of maturity. One side thinks courage is
making a tough choice to end a child's life. The other side thinks courage
means dealing in a life-affirming way with all the obstacles that we know
a pregnant woman in a crisis faces.
If a filmmaker brought that story line to a studio executive, the initial
response would probably be less than positive. But if that filmmaker could
summon up the courage to stay the course, he or she might not only create
an artistic triumph worthy of an Oscar, but also make a real contribution
to a fuller, more nuanced understanding of the women and men who have
dedicated their lives to finding a solution where everyone wins.
|