|
by Anne Morse
(Editor's note: This column first ran in November, 2000.)
I know you're on Thanksgiving vacation, but I'm
giving you a quick pop quiz, anyway. It's
multiple choice, so it won't strain your
mid-term exam exhausted brains too much.
What do we celebrate on
Thanksgiving?
1) It's a feast day honoring the ancient god,
pigus dermus.
2) It's the festival of the ancient god, pigus
outus.
3) It's a feast commemorating the bravery of
the Pilgrim fathers and mothers, who set sail
one day on a three hour cruise, and washed
up 3,000 miles later on uncharted Cape Cod.
On Thanksgiving, who's the one getting
thanked?
1) The Indians
2) Mother Earth
3) the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.
Why did the Pilgrims leave England for
America?
1) They were seeking religious freedom
2) They were searching for a better
environment for their out-of-control kids in a
country totally devoid of pubs and
prostitutes
3) They were attempting to escape the
endless recounts of election ballots in the
1620 "Battle for the Throne."
4) It's a trick question. The Pilgrims actually
came to America from Holland.
Should we continue celebrating
Thanksgiving today?
1) No, the holiday is sexist; the Indian men
didn't allow their squaws to attend the
festivities, and the Pilgrim mothers had to do
all the cooking while their menfolk invented
football.
2) No, the holiday victimizes millions of
turkeys.
3) Yes, we can always use an excuse to get
out of school for a week, pig out on pumpkin
pie, watch football and get mom to do eleven
weeks' worth of laundry.
Okay, how'd you do? If you're like a lot of
collegians, you don't know as much about
Thanksgiving's origins as you thought.
It's really not your fault. The holiday has fallen
into politically-correct disrepute, prey to the
same forces that have polluted the rest of our
culture.
Walk into a Border's Books, you'll find plenty of
books about Thanksgiving. But most of them
offer a deeply distorted view of the holiday. For
instance, readers will get the distinct
impression that the Pilgrims were atheists,
because all mention of God has been omitted
from many a modern holiday tale.
Pilgrim motives are under assault, as well.
Some books, and even the exhibit in
Plymouth, Mass. suggest that the Pilgrims
came to America hoping to become
Elizabethan versions of Bill Gates and Warren
Buffet: they claim that the Pilgrims came to
America for economic opportunity.
Give me a break! If money had been important
to these families, they would never have left
England in the first place. Most suffered
serious financial reversals when they fled their
homeland — reversals that dogged them the
rest of their lives.
Still other books suggest the Pilgrims held
their feast in order to thank the Indians.
Wrong! Assuredly, certain Indians — Squanto,
especially — were key to the Pilgrims' survival.
But despite illness, homesickness the death
of half their members the previous winter, and
the on-going difficulty of scratching out a living
in an unknown land, the Pilgrims thanked God
for blessing them.
Actually, the fact that they spent three days
thanking God instead of cursing Him tells you
much about what the Pilgrims were really
about. Their story began some 14 years prior
to the Mayflower voyage. In England, in the
early Seventeenth century, you were a
member of the Church of England — or you
were in trouble. In 1606, those who objected
to aspects of church doctrine formed their
own, secret congregations, and were known
as Separatists. These worshippers were
persecuted by government authorities,
prompting the Separatists to flee England for
Holland in 1608.
While they now enjoyed religious freedom,
they also suffered desperate poverty. Most had
been farmers in England; now they sought
work as wool combers, tailors, pipe makers
and carpenters. They were growing old before
their time, and becoming discouraged.
But the Separatists had an even greater
concern than putting food on the table. Their
kids were assimilating a little too well into
Dutch culture — an aspect of the Pilgrim story
we hear little about today.
Pick up a copy of William Bradford's diary —
assuming you can find the diary of this dead
white European male anywhere on your
campus — and flip it open. You'll find him
anguishing over the way the congregation's
teenagers were imitating the bad behavior of
Dutch teens. Of all the sorrows to be born,
Bradford writes, the heaviest was that many of
their children, observing "the great
licentiousness of youth in that countrie and the
manifold temptations of the place, were
drawne away by evill examples into
extravagante and dangerous courses, getting
the raines off their neks, and departing from
their parents." Some of them tended to
"dissolutnes and the danger of their soules, to
the great greefe of their parents and dishonor
of God," Bradford notes.
Bradford puts the lie to the notion that the
Pilgrims traveled to the New World to get rich
quick. He writes that, while the Separatists
hoped that day to day life would be a bit easier
in America, their chief motivations were the
spiritual welfare of their children and "a great
hope and inward zeall [for] laying some good
foundation ... for the propagating and
advancing the gospell of the kingdom of
Christ" in "the vast and unpeopled countries of
America."
Although the plan to leave Holland "caused
many fears and doubts amongst them
selves," and some, "out of their fears ... sought
to diverte from it," the little band ultimately
decided that "the dangers were great, but not
desperate; the difficulties were many, but not
invincible," and that "through the help of God,
by fortitude and patience," these difficulties
"might either be borne or overcome," Bradford
records.
Thus, a dozen years after leaving England, the
Separatists prepared to travel to the New
World. As soon as they were able, they sailed
back to England and picked up additional
passengers — fellow saints as well as a
number of strangers whose willingness to go
along helped pay the costs of the journey.
They then set sail on the Mayflower to "those
remote parts of the world," as Bradford put it.
Landing on Cape Cod instead of Virginia, as
they'd expected, the Pilgrims endured a harsh
New England winter that took the lives of half
their number. In the spring, they recovered
from their illnesses, built homes and planted
English barley, peas and wheat, plus twenty
acres of Indian corn, aided by Squanto. In
April, the Mayflower's Captain Christopher
Jones set sail for England. Despite the terrible
winter and anticipated future hardships, not a
single Pilgrim went back with him.
That fall — in October, not November — the
Pilgrims gathered in their harvest and spent
three days feasting. And while contemporary
authors claim this was nothing more than a
day of celebration, William Bradford writes that
it was a day of thanksgiving to God: "The Lord
sent [us] such seasonable showers that
through his blessing [there was] a fruitful and
liberal harvest ... For which mercy ... they set
apart a day of thanksgiving."
That day turned into three, marking both
America's first three-day weekend and the first
church potluck. The Pilgrims invited
Massasoit, chief of the Wampanoag Indians,
who arrived with 90 braves and five
freshly-slaughtered deer; the Pilgrims
provided everything else. The first
Thanksgiving menu is described in The
Pilgrim Way, by Robert M. Bartlett:
"The Pilgrims furnished geese, ducks, and
turkey brought down by their matchlocks. They
spread rough tables with a tempting array of
these meats, along with lobster, clams, fish,
eels, beans, pumpkin, salads of leeks and
water cress, corn cakes, Indian pudding
sweetened with wild honey, grapes, plums
and red and white wine made from wild
grapes."
Evidently, the idea of stuffing ourselves as well
as the turkey originated with the Pilgrims. We
can also credit (or blame) them for blending
Thanksgiving feasting with football. On that
first Thanksgiving weekend, nearly 400 years
ago, the women cooked while the men took
part in various sports and contests of skill. (At
least the Pilgrims burned off their culinary
excesses instead of simply plopping down in
front of the TV, their eyes as glazed as the
Thanksgiving yams.)
Given that the Pilgrims embodied so much of
what Americans value, it's a pity we remember
them primarily for inviting their friends over for
a big meal and sports. We ought to remember
them, as well, for having the courage to face
down dangers and hardships, their defiance
of a government that attempted to dictate how
they should worship, and their insistence on
putting radical obedience to God — and their
commitment to their kids' spiritual welfare —
above a comfortable lifestyle.
Even Christians are beginning to forget what
the Pilgrims were all about. On Thanksgiving,
we tend to content ourselves with a prayer of
thanks to God for our blessings — a brief
prayer, so the gravy won't get cold.
But the story of the Pilgrims is a heritage we
need to protect. If we don't, we may soon see
the day when Thanksgiving is treated as
Columbus Day is in some cities: a day to be
marked with contempt. Already the cultural
corrupters are portraying the Pilgrims as the
original religious zealots who stole land (and
great holiday recipes) from the Indians;
people who intended to force their morality
down other people's throats — as soon as
they arrived, that is.
For example, on the Mall in Washington D.C.
this week, we find Native American Indian
Nathan Philips and his family camped out in a
teepee. They're there, he informed the
Washington Post, as part of a nationwide
commemoration of Thanksgiving as a "day of
mourning" to "remind people that a lot of
American Indians don't have too much to be
thankful for."
So: This is the fault of the Pilgrims? The folks
who signed and kept a 55-year peace treaty
with Massasoit, the Wampanoag Indian chief
who welcomed the Pilgrims as friends?
If we want to avoid being influenced by
revisionist history, we Need to make sure we
know the truth about the Pilgrims. You can find
it in diaries written by Pilgrim fathers William
Bradford and Edward Winslow, and books by
historians like Robert M. Bartlett, author of
The Pilgrim Way.
Ultimately, the Pilgrims are a reminder to
comfortable American Christians that
following Christ means being willing to give
up everything for Him: Mother and father,
home and jobs, comfort and amusements,
the familiarity of our own country and a
predictable future of prosperity. The Pilgrims
were willing. Are we?
This question isn't on the pop quiz — but it's
the most important one of all, one we should
ponder as we chow down on the turkey and
pumpkin pies this Thanksgiving day.
|