Finish Rich or Finish Right (or Both)?

Jan 26, 2006 |Heather Koerner

A popular financial author advises how you can "finish rich." But is that what a Christian should be concerned with?

Financial author David Bach has been popping up everywhere. From Business Week to Glamour, from CNN to Oprah, Bach has been telling America how to, using his well-known catch phrase, "finish rich." In fact, "finish rich" is his mantra, the title of his website and in the title of most of his books.

Finishing rich doesn't sound too bad. A lot better to most of us than finishing poor. So, I wondered. What is his advice and, as a Christian, should I follow it? A few mouse clicks and a few days later, I had a copy of Bach's most recent book, The Automatic Millionaire.

Before even beginning it, I admit, I had some doubts. This is no slam on Bach in particular. Let's just call it a general leeriness about the secular financial world. Money is seductive, as is advice on how to make the most of it. Too often I've found myself listening to a financial guru, nodding my head and thinking, "Yeah, that could work for me!"

But there's one big problem with that: These experts and I are coming from completely different perspectives. The goal of their advice, simply, is to have enough. Have enough for retirement, or enough to feel safe, or enough to live out my dreams, or enough to whatever. My goal as a Christian is righteousness. Instead of having enough, I want to be right with God. He is my provider. I am only the steward. If I don't get that straight, it doesn't matter how much I'm sticking into my 401 (k).

So, I've learned I need to be cautious when taking financial advice. My question can't be "Will this work?" It has to be "Is this what God wants me doing with His money?" As long as I keep that straight then maybe I can pick up a few tips from the gurus.

So that's how I approached Bach's book. Not looking for an overall financial strategy — God's already got one for me — but looking for a few little nuggets. I found some good tips, one thing I would take issue with, and one pleasant surprise.

We'll start with the good tips.

First, Bach says, you have to start saving right now, no matter your income. You don't have to earn more to increase your savings, Bach insists, you simply have to spend less. Someone earning $20,000 a year and spending $17,000 is much better off than someone earning $500,000 and spending $525,000.

Think you don't have the money to save? Bach says to look at your "latte factor" — a phrase which came from Bach's encounter with a seminar student who insisted she didn't have one nickel a day to invest for retirement.

But when Bach had "Kim" list her daily expenses, she admitted starting each day with a $3.50 latte and $1.50 muffin. Before even getting to work, Kim spent five dollars that — if she had homemade coffee and a cereal bar — could be saved. Kim's five dollars a day, invested with a return of 10 percent, would yield her $948,611 at the end of 40 years.

Bach's question is simple. That latte (or lunch out or bottled water or car wash) is nice, and it's not that you don't deserve it, but would you be willing to give it up to have a million dollars for retirement?

Bach's next step is to pay yourself first and make it automatic.

Before you and I were born, Americans used to pay their income taxes in one lump sum each year. Unfortunately, they often hadn't saved the money to pay the tax bill. The government's solution? Take the money automatically from our checks.

"Think about that for a second," Bach writes. "The government is pretty smart. It figured out years ago that people couldn't budget, so it set up a system to make sure it got 'paid first' ... [and] it automated the process so there wouldn't be any slip-ups."

Bach advises that we do the same thing — having 10 percent of our income automatically deducted from our paycheck and put into a pretax retirement account. By doing this, we're taking our will power out of the equation. The decision is made once, and we're done. "What makes this possible is very simple: you can't spend what you don't have in your pocket," Bach writes. "So even if you think the most you could part with right now is just 1 percent of your gross income, that's okay — go ahead and get started." Bach's personal experience, and mine too, is that when the money never hits your account, you don't miss it. It may sound trite, but it's true. Try it.

So far, so good. As Christians, we can definitely examine our own "latte factors" to find money to save. Then, by saving automatically, we're guaranteeing we get it done.

Bach's next recommendation, however, I have to take issue with. It's this: Buy a home now. Why pay rent and own nothing, when you could put the same amount towards a mortgage and own your home, he asks. In addition, by paying off your mortgage early, you save thousands of dollars in interest payments and own it debt-free even sooner.

Good points, both. But here's the catch. Just as Bach has seen the little things — the lattes — get in the way of financial progress, I have seen the big thing — specifically, a house — stand firmly in many peoples' way.

Rather than making the mistake of non-homeownership, I believe too many of us make the mistake of too much home ownership. We buy homes that banks promise we can "afford," only to find that when life happens — babies or illnesses or layoffs — we can't afford them after all.

Further, instead of buying and paying off, many of us buy then move then move again. We start our 30-year mortgages over again and again, only to find that we're facing retirement with a debt-laden house and no ownership in sight.

I think Bach is right that home ownership is a good thing, as is paying off your mortgage early. But, as Christians, we need to be careful. If our mortgage will compete with our family's needs or our obligations to God, we need to wait or buy less.

Speaking of our obligations to God, I found the last chapter of The Automatic Millionaire a pleasant surprise: "Make a Difference with Automatic Tithing." The fact that a secular author would even mention tithing got me giddy. "Money will not give your life meaning," Bach writes, "It really won't.... With tithing, the more you give, the better you feel."

Bach recommends making your giving automatic as well — just like your retirement payments. This has worked well for me. The church takes my tithe from my checking account each month, and I don't have to remember or scramble.

However, Bach's definition of tithing and mine differ, as do the reasons for doing it. Bach advocates giving to whatever charity you feel comfortable with, reasoning that tithing makes you feel great and "abundance tends to flow back to those who give." As a Christian, God has commanded me to tithe to Him and while it does make me feel good, that's not why I do it. I do it because I love Him and I show that love through obedience.

So this chapter was a good reminder of my original concerns. David Bach has some good ideas and reading his book encouraged me to set some new savings goals for the coming year. But my finances belong to God. I save for retirement because He has commanded me to emulate the ant and store up provisions — not to finish rich.

Like Paul, I want to finish the race having kept the faith. Can I finish rich and still finish right? Perhaps. But, as Matthew 6:24 says, I'm going to have to choose one as my goal. I can't serve both.

Copyright 2006 Heather Koerner. All rights reserved.


Like what you see?

If you’ve enjoyed this article, will you consider giving a tax-deductible gift to Boundless right now? We’re a donor-funded ministry, and we rely on friends like you to help keep us going! DONATE NOW »

  • .

Weekly Boundless goodness in your inbox

Sign up for our e-newsletter and receive a free chapter from the hit book, The Dating Manifesto, by Lisa Anderson.